redhotcurry.com - all the curry & more!
 
  
Home | Feedback | About Us | Sitemap
 
USA/CANADA : USA Site News | Business | Films | Galleries | Music | Theatre
UK NEWS & BUSINESS :  UK Site News | Business | Money | Property | Views
ENTERTAINMENT : BooksFestivals | Bollywood | Bollywood News | Bollywood Films | Films
Galleries | Museums | Music | Parties | Theatre | Television
LIFESTYLE : Culture | Eating Out  | Food & Drink | Health | Horoscopes | Home Decor | Garden
Shop | Style | Sports : MPCL | TravelWeddings
MEMBER SERVICES Directory | eGreetings Cardsenewsletters | Wallpapers | Sign-up | DiscussChat | Email
SHOP:
Search | Categories | Basket | Speed Order | Shipping | Account | Terms | Refunds | Wish List
 
 
NEWS ARCHIVE 2001 - 2003
 
 
Google
Search Web
Search Redhotcurry.com
 
   Archived News -> Sentences reduced for Bradford rioters  
 

Click here to view current News Stories


Religious Freedom is a Core British Belief (12/03)

Asians on Fast-Track in Police Service (12/03)

Prison Service guilty of racial discrimination (12/03)

Mayor's reception for BME Councillors (12/03)

Muslim Youth Helpline Wins Award (12/03)

Cracking Crime II (12/03)

Asians Boost London's Economy (12/03)

Reuben Singh puts his faith in Timebank (11/03)

Crackdown on Time Share & Holiday Clubs (11/03)

Asian named 'National Warden of the Year' (11/03)

Sanjeev Bhaskar awarded honorary doctorate (11/03)

Young Asian Girl wins CAB Award (11/03)

Mayor invites Asians to London Debate (11/03)

Big Shakeout in Indian Outsourcing (11/03)

South Yorkshire wins Diversity Awards (11/03)

Diversity in Towns & Cities is crucial (11/03)

Nominate a Gem - Asian Jewel Awards 2004 (11/03)

New Forum to strengthen equality in the NHS (10/03)

Hewitt announces Equality Commission (10/03)

CRE to investigate the Police Service (10/03)

Police Force pulled down by Officers (10/03)

Carlton Multicultural Awards 2003 (10/03)

So you think you're Multicultural? (10/03)

British Asian girl wins Beacon Fellowship (10/03)

Nazia Hassan Foundation honours Asians (10/03)

'Enough is Enough' say the UK's Black Police (10/03)

Labour Party guilty of racial discrimination (10/03)

Mayor supports more Asian Councillors (10/03)

Redhotcurry shortlisted for BIMA Awards 2003 (10/03)

UK's Best 100 Diversity Practitioners (09/03)

Ethnic Minorities encouraged into Law (09/03)

ICAN Foundation's "Fame Academy" (09/03)

"University Challenge" India proves a winner! (09/03)

Operation Hindu Vote launched (09/03)

Asian Youth debate Money, Drugs & Sex! (09/03)

Football for All? (09/03)

"Life's a pitch!", IPA tells Asian Students (09/03)

Ad Agencies wake up to ethnic minorities (09/03)

TUC launches Anti-Racism Strategy (09/03)

Politicians to address Equality Question (09/03)

Redhotcurry shortlisted for AOP Awards 2003 (09/03)

Bollywood mag 'Cineblitz' relaunched (09/03)

UK Asian Rugby? (09/03)

Pakistan Development Fund-raiser (09/03)

Asians urged to recycle more (09/03)

Europe's first Asian Football Festival (09/03)

Charities need to target Asians (08/03)

Time for Change in Burnley (08/03)

Asian Jewel Awards (07/03)

Sardar Patel University appeals to Indians (07/03)

Asians urged to nominate for £20,000 Award (07/03)

CRE reports on murder of Zahid Mubarek (07/03)

Peter Mandelson solidifies UK links with India (07/03)

Only Whites in Senior Civil Service Jobs (07/03)

EU fails Ethnic Minorities (07/03)

Carlton Awards - Call for Entries (07/03)

'Totally London' Soho Street Party (06/03)

Asian Portal scoops Windrush Award (06/03)

UK's FTSE companies fail Ethnic Minorities (06/03)

CRE supports rural race equality schemes (06/03)

CRE asks Brent to act on racial inequalities (06/03)

Gurinder Chadha wins top AWA Award 2003 (05/03)

EMMA Awards 2003 Launch Party (05/03)

Gangsters for Life? (05/03)

BNP voters mistaken says Trevor Phillips (05/03)

Ken Livingstone loves a curry (05/03)

Dynamic Asian Women's Network Launches (05/03)

Competition heats up for AWA Awards (04/03)

A R Rahman savours Brummie culture (04/03)

Launch of 'Asians in Media' Networking Group (04/03)

Curry Entrepreneur helps Cancer Charity (04/03)

Ms Dynamite wins Top RIMA Award 2003 (04/03)

Asians must vote on May 1st (04/03)

Help the Aged strengthens ties with India (03/03)

Britain's Richest Asians - the Rich List 2003 (03/03)

Karachi's Deputy Mayor at City Hall (03/03)

Ethnic Marketing: A double- edged sword (03/03)

Windrush Awards 2003 - Teachers sought (03/03)

Government reassures Muslim Community (03/03)

Mayor meets with Muslim Community Leaders (03/03)

EMMA 2003 - Last Call for Nominations (02/03)

AWA 2003 - Last Call for Nominations (02/03)

Shabana Azmi to speak at Capitalwoman (02/03)

Asif Kapadia wins two BAFTA Awards (02/03)

Asians missing out on Lottery funding (02/03)

Mayor focuses on Asian creative talent (02/03)

Sentences reduced for Bradford rioters (02/03)

BNP Victory due to frenzy over asylum (01/03)

BNP win fifth Council Seat (01/03)

Trevor Phillips announced as CRE Chair (01/03)

Record Number of Ethnic Staff at Home Office (01/03)


 
 

SENTENCES REDUCED FOR BRADFORD RIOTERS
(1 February 2003). By Arun Kundnani, Reprinted by permission of the IRR.

Campaigners for 'Fair Justice For All' demand proprotionate sentencing for the Bradford RiotersIn what has effectively become a test case for the sentencing of hundreds of Asians charged with participating in the Bradford riot of July 2001, the Court of Appeal has ruled that four individuals were given excessive sentences but a further eleven did deserve terms of between four and six-and-a-half years.

During a two-day hearing, Michael Mansfield QC highlighted the 'matrix of fear' which the Asian community was under, a factor explicitly ignored by the original judgment. But Lord Justice Rose, sitting with two other appeal judges, did not make any direct criticism of Judge Gullick, the Recorder of Bradford, who passed most of the original sentences.

Rose did, however, describe as 'unfortunate' Gullick's statement that he was 'not concerned with the origins of the violence'. If, by that, Gullick meant that the causes of the riot were irrelevent to the court, then he was wrong, said Rose. The Court of Appeal ruled that the riot was almost certainly triggered by the stabbing of an Asian man in central Bradford and that 'the Asian community was understandably concerned to defend itself against right-wing groups'.

But, Rose added, as events unfolded, what had begun as a spontaneous reaction became marked by pre-meditation. The riot then became directed at the police who were trying to move Asians out of central Bradford into the Manningham area, the heart of Bradford's Pakistani community. Rose condemned the 'defiance of the young' which, he said, resisted the peacemaking efforts of Asian elders.

Wives, mothers and sisters of those serving sentences were left in tears and said they were devastated by the verdict. They had organised a campaigning group - Fair Justice For All - to demand proportionate sentencing. High-profile supporters, such as actor Art Malik and musician Aki Nawaz, had offered their support and Imran Khan became their solicitor. Lord Ouseley, who had produced a widely respected report on the racial problems faced by Bradford, also warned that the long sentences would do little to help heal the city's wounds. The campaigners accepted that custodial sentences were appropriate but drew attention to the much lower sentences given to white youths who rioted on the Ravenscliffe Estate, one day after the Manningham riot. Last year, David Blunkett denounced the Fair Justic For All campaigners as 'maniacs' who were 'whining' about the sentences.

EXCESSIVE SENTENCING?

More than a hundred Asians have now been convicted of riot for involvement in the Bradford disturbances. The majority have handed themselves in to the police, pleaded guilty and had no relevant previous convictions. Most have been sentenced to between four and six-and-a-half years. Under 18s have been given between six and eighteen months detention.

The guidelines laid down by the Court of Appeal this week indicate that, given the particular circumstances of this riot, somebody present for a short period who threw stones at the police, should expect a sentence of five years (before any discount for a guilty plea). Someone whom a court finds to be a ringleader should expect a sentence of ten years (before any discount).

Normally the courts would reduce the sentence by a third if the defendant offered a guilty plea. But the Appeal Court judges ruled that a discount of less than a third should apply in cases such as these, where the evidence against the defendants was overwhelming. Evidence collected from CCTV footage has proved pivotal in all the trials of Bradford rioters.

On the basis of these guidelines, four of the defendants were entitled to have their sentences reduced because of individual factors, rather than any general concession. Shakeel Qazi's sentence was reduced from four years to two years, in recognition of his diminished responsibility - Shakeel, 22, suffers from bipolar affective disorder. Shazad Ali, 22, had his sentence reduced from four years to three, because of his short involvement and his having a place at university. Parvais Najeeb, 28, had his sentence cut from four years to three and Mohammed Maskin, 27, had his cut from two years and nine months to two years.

Imran Khan said that the Court of Appeal verdict meant that 'the context in which the riots took place should have been taken into account and we hope that those who have yet to be sentenced in relation to the riots will be appropriately dealt with'. Around another twenty people, charged with involvement in the Bradford riot and also being represented by Imran Khan, are still awaiting trial.

Because almost all the defendants have so far pleaded guilty, many issues regarding the events of 7 and 8 July 2001 have yet to emerge in a courtroom to be tested in front of a jury. In particular, campaigners believe that the issue of police tactics has not been fully examined. In October 2002, a jury acquitted a group of Asian men of a charge of violent disorder, on the basis that, during the riot in Burnley in June 2001, they were legitimately carrying weapons and acting in self-defence because of the failure of the police to adequately protect them from white racists.

Click here to visit the Institute of Race Relations (IRR) website.

Top

Promote your business in the RedHot Business Directory. Click here

 
   
 

© 2001-2003. Copyright of Redhotcurry Limited. All Rights Reserved.
Business Information | About us | Opportunities | Press Room | Become a Contributor | Contact Us
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Terms of Contribution | Community Standards