C4
- TAKE 'BIG BROTHER' OFF THE AIR
By Lopa Patel (17 January 2007).
I've
been watching the latest series of Channel 4's reality TV show 'Celebrity
Big Brother' with a growing sense of disbelief at the blatant cynicism
demonstrated by the programme makers in the faceof charges of racism
by housemates. Bollywood actress Shilpa Shetty, the only Asian participant
in this series, has been bullied mercilessly by fellow housemates
all in the name of "so-called" entertainment. Broadcasting
regulator Ofcom has received in the region of 14,500 complaints
about Celebrity Big Brother 2007 (17 Jan 2007) but, as yet, no statement
from Channel 4 or Endemol, the producers of the show.
Bullying
is the crux of this programme, which tries to emulate the tactics
of the fictional 'Big Brother' as featured in George Orwell's book
'1984'. Housemates are locked in a house with no contact with the
outside world; they are limited in the number of personal effects
they can bring into the house and subjected to pointless demeaning
tasks to earn "benefits" whilst being filmed 24x7.
Author
Germaine Greer, writing for 'The Guardian', says that "Big
Brother disorients the housemates and disrupts their perceptions
so that they become literally unbalanced". She adds that "plain,
everyday, common or garden bullying supplies the motive force for
everything that happens in the 'Big Brother' house".
RACIST
BULLYING
From
the outset, Shilpa has had to deal with bullying. Housemate Jackiey
Budden, mother of fellow housemate Jade Goody, was unable to pronounce
the name 'Shilpa' and a heated argument ensued. The episode had
more to do with Jackey's refusal to learn the pronunciation than
the difficulty of actually saying Shilpa's name! This was later
followed by Budden asking Shilpa "Do you live in a house or
a shack?"
Disgraced
'Miss England' contestant Danielle Lloyd complained about Shilpa
eating with her hands and asked if this was normal in India. She
added that she considered this unhygienic. The trio of Lloyd, former
S Club 7 singer Jo O'Meara and Jade Goody complained about the spicy
cooking, although, so far none of them has bothered to offer to
cook. Danielle was further annoyed by the use of onions Shetty used
in her cooking and called the Bollywood star "a dog".
On Monday night's episode, O'Meara reportedly suggested that Indians
were thin because they were always ill as a result of undercooking
their food.
When
housemates discovered Shetty bleaching her facial hairs, they claimed
that it was because she "wanted to be white". Housemates
Jade Goody, Danielle Lloyd and Jo O'Meara have also been seen making
fun of the Bollywood star's accent.
Jade's
boyfriend, Jack Tweed has called Shetty "a c**t" (bleeped
out) and Jade branded Shilpa as "pathetic, fake and a liar"
in a row over stock cubes. It is quite clear that by allowing Jade,
her mother and her boyfriend to be in the house at the same time,
he producers were "fixing" the show to be an explosive
mixture of xenophobia and school-playground politics.
SHETTY
REPRESENTS THE ASIAN COMMUNITY
Film
maker Ken Russell and singer Leo Sayer have already left the show
voluntarily; Jackiey Budden was voted out by the public, as was
journalist Carol Malone who gave some insight into Shilpa's mindset
in the house in a BBC Asian Network interview on Monday. Speaking
about Shilpa's feelings on the bullying Carol said, "Shilpa
feels that she represents the Indian/ Asian community and doesn't
want to let them or herself down by retaliating. She's a very dignified
woman and she doesn't want to lose it. That's why she's desperately
trying to keep it all together". Carol added "she's an
incredibly powerful and beautiful woman. (Shilpa) is a very strong
woman and can handle it. I spoke to her about it when I was in the
house".
EARLY
DAY MOTION IN HOUSE OF COMMONS
MP
Keith Vaz has tabled an Early Day Motion in the House of Commons
stating "That this House views with concern the comments made
about Big Brother contestant Shilpa Shetty by other housemates;
believes that Big Brother has a role to play in preventing racist
behaviour in the Big Brother house; regrets that these comments
have been made; and calls on the programme to take urgent action
to remind housemates that racist behaviour is unacceptable.".
The
EDM is supported by other politicians including Shadow Spokesman
on Community Cohesion, Dominic Grieve who said "it is quite
wrong that the programme should tolerate racist abuse and behaviour
from participants and I believe it is an issue that should be addressed
immediately."
EVICT
RACIST HOUSEMATES
The
programme makers have yet to respond to the complaints but as rule
number (14) THE MOST IMPORTANT RULE OF ALL: Big Brother reserves
the right to change the rules at any time, they could add a new
rule to prevent racism, sexism, xenophobia and bigotry and then
evoke rule (13) which states that if any housemate breaks the rules
they may be asked to leave the House!
TAKE
'BIG BROTHER' OFF THE AIR
Although
political pressure and complaints may lead Channel 4 and the producers
to reconsider their "House Rules", they are unlikely to
be able to pull the programme "off the air". Ofcom's list
of Sanctions that it can impose on TV states that "It can direct
a broadcaster not to repeat material; direct a broadcaster to publish
a correction or summary of a finding or adjudication; fine a broadcaster;
and, with the exception of the BBC, Channel 4 and S4C, shorten or
revoke a licence."
However,
salvation may yet come from Advertisers on the show. Charles Dunstone,
the Chief Executive of Carphone Warehouse told 'The Times' that
he was in talks with bosses at Channel 4 due to concerns about the
treatment of Shetty and that he is reviewing the firm's £3m
annual sponsorship deal of the show. Undoubtedly, there will be
a termination clause should Carphone Warehouse feel that their brand
name is being brought into disrepute because of the show.
The
racist bullying has attracted comments from many other well know
Asian Stars including Meera Syal who told the 'Evening Standard'
that "there is a very thin line between what is entertainment
and a vile spectacle and I think we are in that area now".
Syal added that "this is bullying and we mustn't forget the
impressionable people who watch this show".
HOW
TO COMPLAIN ABOUT 'BIG BROTHER' - HAVE YOUR SAY
If
you agree with this viewpoint and would like to have your complaint
heard. Contact Ofcom- click below to register your complaint.
http://www.ofcom.org.uk/complain/progs/bb/?itemid=363194
Ofcom
Tel: 020 7981 3040
Ofcom Fax: 020 7981 3334
|